This is a favorite ploy of right-wingers like Paul Ryan, blame the poor, working, and middle-classes and call them names like “unpatriotic” for making perfectly rational decisions. If Paul were making a working class salary, I’d like to see him figure out how to pay childcare costs for a 2nd or 3rd child, when he and his wife were working full-time. busting a gut, to pay the bills with just one child. It is the anti-working-people policies of the right: slashing the safety net, bashing unions, reducing support for working families that is one of the main forces driving lower birth rates.
Take a look at the advanced countries of Europe and Asia. There are some frightening cautionary tales. Most of those countries are currently in a low-fertility trap. Because of these countries’ low-birth rates, each generation is smaller than the previous, which means that there are fewer women of reproductive age in each successive generation, who in turn have still fewer children for the next generation. If Paul Ryan were familiar with the extensive demographic research that has been done on the topic, he would know that the very few countries that have been able to avoid the low-fertility trap, like France and the Scandinavian countries, provide robust and comprehensive support for young families, like extended, paid-parental leave for new parents, heavily subsidized childcare, etc. Thank God for immigration or the American economy in the long-term may be doomed to experience a shrinking employment base with an ever-increasing number of the aging to support. Can you say “Japan”?